Current:Home > Contact-usJudge weighs the merits of a lawsuit alleging ‘Real Housewives’ creators abused a cast member-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Judge weighs the merits of a lawsuit alleging ‘Real Housewives’ creators abused a cast member
View Date:2024-12-23 15:05:04
NEW YORK (AP) — The lawyer for a former cast member of the “Real Housewives of New York” told a federal judge Thursday that the First Amendment cannot shield the show’s creators from a lawsuit alleging that the show’s participants were subjected to a “rotted workplace culture.”
Attorney Sarah Matz said the lawsuit brought by Leah McSweeney earlier this year should advance to the stage where evidence can be gathered for trial.
Adam Levin, a lawyer for defendants including entertainer Andy Cohen, one of the show’s producers, and the Bravo channel, told the judge that the lawsuit’s allegations were protected by the First Amendment and that it should be dismissed at a stage in which the judge is required to assume the allegations are true.
The judge did not immediately rule on the future of the lawsuit, which seeks unspecified damages for mental, emotional, physical pain along with impairment of life’s joys and lost future earnings.
The lawsuit filed in Manhattan federal court alleges that McSweeney, who suffers from alcoholism, was pressured to drink booze on the show and was retaliated against when she wanted to stay sober or was denied reasonable accommodations to aid her efforts at sobriety.
It also alleges that the defendants “employed psychological warfare intentionally weaponized to break Ms. McSweeney’s psyche,” particularly when she was intimidated and prevented from visiting her dying grandmother through threats to cut her pay or fire her if she left the filming location.
“They knew she was trying to be sober,” Matz told the judge. “The show is not called the ‘Drunk Housewives of New York City.’”
The judge, who said he had never seen the show, asked each side numerous questions and seemed inclined to, at a minimum, strike some allegations from the lawsuit that pertained to events on camera.
Levin told him the lawsuit should be tossed in its entirety. He said ruling in favor of the claims made in McSweeney’s lawsuit “would kill” some television and Broadway stage shows if the First Amendment did not protect the producers of shows.
Particularly when it comes to a reality television show, the cast member becomes the message of the show and “you can’t separate the person from the speech,” Levin said.
“What are the limits a director can do to induce the behavior the director wants?” the judge asked as he questioned whether a director could demand that show participants not sleep for two days before filming or subject themselves to a physical assault just before they go on camera.
Levin said there were limits to First Amendment protection for the creators of a communicative show, but he said they were narrow in scope. McSweeney’s lawsuit, he said, did not fall within the narrow exceptions, such as when a producer might commit a criminal felony offense during the production of a show.
veryGood! (324)
Related
- Why Game of Thrones' Maisie Williams May Be Rejoining the George R.R. Martin Universe
- Clothes That Show Your Pride: Rainbow Fleece Pants, Sweaters, Workout Leggings & More
- Mental health respite facilities are filling care gaps in over a dozen states
- James Lewis, prime suspect in the 1982 Tylenol murders, found dead
- Congress heard more testimony about UFOs: Here are the biggest revelations
- At One of America’s Most Toxic Superfund Sites, Climate Change Imperils More Than Cleanup
- Father drowns in pond while trying to rescue his two daughters in Maine
- Has Conservative Utah Turned a Corner on Climate Change?
- Jared Goff stats: Lions QB throws career-high 5 INTs in SNF win over Texans
- New York’s Heat-Vulnerable Neighborhoods Need to Go Green to Cool Off
Ranking
- Man is 'not dead anymore' after long battle with IRS, which mistakenly labeled him deceased
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dimitris Giannetos Shares the $10 Must-Have To Hide Grown-Out Roots and Grey Hair
- Biden signs a bill to fight expensive prison phone call costs
- Covid Killed New York’s Coastal Resilience Bill. People of Color Could Bear Much of the Cost
- Skai Jackson announces pregnancy with first child: 'My heart is so full!'
- New York opens its first legal recreational marijuana dispensary
- Coco Austin Twins With Daughter Chanel During Florida Vacation
- Clean Energy Loses Out in Congress’s Last-Minute Budget Deal
Recommendation
-
West Virginia governor-elect Morrisey to be sworn in mid-January
-
New Arctic Council Reports Underline the Growing Concerns About the Health and Climate Impacts of Polar Air Pollution
-
Powerball jackpot now 9th largest in history
-
New York opens its first legal recreational marijuana dispensary
-
Cruise ship rescues 4 from disabled catamaran hundreds of miles off Bermuda, officials say
-
A golden age for nonalcoholic beers, wines and spirits
-
The attack on Brazil's Congress was stoked by social media — and by Trump allies
-
How Buying A Home Became A Key Way To Build Wealth In America